A response to Dave Winer

Submitted by Bill St. Clair on Tue, 10 Nov 2026 10:12:34 GMT  <== Politics ==> 

Dave Winer's blog today has made me want to respond.

I, too, was accustomed to writing a political blog (this one). But a lot changed for me in November of 2020 (when my programming muse left, and I had to retire), I had already become mostly non-political, finally realizing the truth of one of my favorite quotes (which I said, intellectually, long before I realized its truth):

"There is no political solution to any problem. Politics is itself the cause of most of the problems it purports to solve." -- Bill St. Clair

So how are problems solved? By individuals, often joining together in teams, solving them. I think it was The Mythical Man-Month that said that software is written by teams with a maximum of ten members. Nowadays, some choose to leverage LLMs (Large Language Model software, aka AI).

Dave DOES this, but he SAYS politics is important. I have decided that politics is a waste of my time. The state is decidedly evil, but it is not necessary. Why America's founders thought differently, I don't know. They were young.

Humans cannot usefully interact in groups larger than a tribe. Once there are members of the group that you don't know, personally, the group is too large for you. Once evil notices that it can control a large group, it will. Our job is to ensure that nobody has the power to control any group we choose to join, without unanimous consent.

I had other thoughts while reading Dave's post, but they have disappeared in writing this one.

Add comment Edit post Add post